[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
[ccp4bb]: Summary: refining OCC's of alternate configs
*** For details on how to be removed from this list visit the ***
*** CCP4 home page http://www.dl.ac.uk/CCP/CCP4/main.html ***
Thought I'd pass along a summary of a question I asked
a few weeks ago.
I have alternate configurations of active site contents.
I wanted to know the best way to refine the occupancies
of the 2 different configurations.
The alternate configs come from a reaction in the active
site of the form: A + B -> C + D, were there is a mixture
of products and unreacted reactants seen.
Summary of answers:
I got 3 basic answers:
1) Proceed with caution because OCC's and B's are
absolutely coupled and what you choose for one will
effect the other.
2) Use SHELX
3) Use CNS
#1 above: #1 above is true, of course. A method that
someone suggested to exercise this caution is...
>Depending on your resolution, I would opt to only refine B's
>and adjust the occupancies manually.
With this, you can make an initial guess at the relative
OCC's based on the density, then refine B's. Presuming
the B's for config_1 and config_2 are similar, you can
manually adjust OCC's until the B's for the 2 configs
are similar to each other.
#3 above: The authors have told me that they have not
implimented the option to refine OCC's for alternate configs.
Many people insisted that you _can_ use CNS, but I think I
believe the authors on this one.
Someone suggested this manual adjust to the CNS limitation:
>I used the alternate conformations feature in CNS to refine
>my substrate with two different puckers.
>then used the q-group protocul to define the occupancy
>for each conformation.
>Then manually adjust the occ to be sure it adds up to one.
But, since my substrate is in the form
A + B -> C + D
and I know that if A is 80% occupied, then neither C nor D
can be greater than 20%... I can say with firm certainty
that this manual adjust is not accurate.
#2 above: I have not tried SHELX, but this seems the best
option for high resolution data.
donate free food www.thehungersite.com
diane h peapus, phd firstname.lastname@example.org
Chemistry & Chemical Biology +1-607-255-2174 (office)
Cornell University +1-607-255-2600 (graph room)
Ithaca, NY 14853 USA +1-607-255-1227 (fax)