[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[ccp4bb]: problem to find the MR solution



Dear fellow crystallographers,

This is only partially related to CCP4, but I hope my fellow crystallographers subscribed to CCP4  list-server would like to give me help and advices.

I have a protein of the size of about 90 kDa.  I have been able to grow very tiny crystals from this protein (about 0.1x0.1x0.05 mm3 in dimension).  The crystals diffracted X-ray better than 3 A.  Even though the diffraction spots are pretty weak, the scaling of the data was pretty good to 3 A with the r-merge of 0.12 and completeness of 99%.   The space group of the crystals is I4.  Analysis of the systematic absence reflections indicated that there is no screw axis, i.e., the space group cannot be I4(1).

I have a structure model from the same kind protein from a different species that was refined to 2.0 A.  The sequence alignment of the two proteins indicated that all important structure elements are conserved.  They share 44% identity in sequence with very few deletions or insertions (3%).  Thus, I thought it would be easy and straightforward to solve the new structure using the MR method.

However, all of my efforts using either CNS or AMORE programs to find the structure solution have failed so far. 

Using CNS, the rotation function search yielded a list of solutions in which the top peaks (over ten peaks) always have the RF-function value of 1.000 (I don¡¯t know what it means here).  The subsequent translation search yielded a list of results with very poor monitor values and packing value.  For space group I4, the translation search should carry out only along x- and y-axes.  But CNS also does the translation search along z-axis. 

Using AMORE, both rotation function search and translation function search resulted no outstanding peaks.  Most of the peaks in the list had correlation coefficient around 0.3-0.4 and R-factor around 0.55. 

I am wondering if there is something wrong with my data or there are other problems too.   Does anyone in the community have similar experience? Does anyone have any clue on what¡¯s going wrong here?  Or does anyone have any suggestions and advices for me?

Thank you very much in advance for your help.

Sincerely yours,

Jianping Ding
CABM and Rutgers University
679 Hoes Lane
Piscataway, NJ 08854